“. . . according to the Yoga Sutra (3.1), the term [Bandha] refers to the ‘binding’ of consciousness to a particular object or locus (desha), which is the very essence of concentration.”
Georg Feuerstein



Saturday, May 20, 2017

Your Glutes in Backbends: Part I

Hello Friends,

In this post we take a look at the glute max in backbends and how to avoid splaying out your knees in poses like Urdhva danurasana (Wheel). I give you some cues for sequencing muscle engagement and also address a misconception about contracting your adductor muscles.

For decades now we’ve heard the instruction in yoga, “soften your glutes in backbends” with no valid explanation why. Your hips are extending in backbends, and your gluteus maximus is the prime mover for that action. Why wouldn’t you want to contract the very muscle that creates that movement?

Let's look closer. When you deliberately soften your glutes, then the hip extension comes from the hamstrings, because your hamstrings work as synergists to the gluteus maximus for this action. So, why not just use your hamstrings to extend the hips and avoid getting scolded for using the prime movers (glutes)? Well, if you do that enough, you potentially set up a muscle imbalance that can lead to “synergistic dominance” wherein the hamstrings become the prime mover of this action. In the hip joint, this can result in abnormal kinematics and, ultimately, pain. I’ll go over some other problems with doing backbends without the glutes in Part II of this series.

One side effect of using your gluteus maximus is that it is also a powerful external rotator of the hip. Thus, when you engage your glute max in a backbend, your hips will rotate outward and your knees tend to splay apart.

Do we care if the knees splay out? Well, it depends on your objective in the pose. Recent literature shows that if the femurs are parallel, you fire your entire gluteus maximus, whereas when they are splayed apart, you fire mainly the upper portion (Selkowitz, 2016).

The “solution” that is usually proposed for this is to have folks try to squeeze a block between their knees to “fire those adductors!” In India, this instruction was often accompanied by much shouting at the frustrated person attempting it. There is a reason, however, why this cue works so poorly, despite the yelling. That is because when your hips are extended (in a backbend), the orientation of the adductor muscle fibers makes them become external rotators of the hip and synergize the gluteus maximus in splaying your knees apart. So it’s a bit like hitting the brakes and gas at the same time. Frustrating. Figure 1 illustrates this.

Figure 1: Note the orientation of the fibers of the adductor group and how contracting these muscles leads to splaying out of the knees in backbends.

The real counterbalance for the gluteus maximus causing the knees to splay apart is to contract the muscles that internally rotate the hips, namely, the TFL and front part of the gluteus medius.

This cue works well, but it must be implemented in a sequence to function optimally. You have to engage the hip internal rotators before going up into the backbend. It's difficult to engage them once you are up in the pose because when the hips are extending, the TFL and front part of the gluteus medius are at a biomechanical disadvantage for initiating contraction. Thus, you want to first train the cue to engage these muscles with the hips flexed, where it is easy to contract them. Then bring in the glute max to do the backbend. I’ve taught this sequence all over the world and had great feedback. Done properly, the muscles form a “sheath” that lifts the pelvis in a balanced and stable fashion. (Figure 2)

Figure 2: Note how the muscles at the front of the hips internally rotate the thighs to balance external rotation from the gluteus maximus.

Here’s the sequence.

Step 1) 

Lie on your back and bend your knees so that your feet are flat on the ground as shown. Place your hands on the front part of the pelvis to feel your internal rotators contract. Now, on exhalation, press the feet down and attempt to scrub them apart while allowing you knees to roll inward. Don’t actually move your feet. You should be able to feel your TFL contract. Release on the inhalation and repeat for about 10 times to train the action. Press your feet down and then attempt to scrub them away from the midline. The feet should remain fixed on your mat, as your knees roll inward and you should feel your muscles contract if you've got it.

Figure 3: Press your feet down and attempt to drag them apart as you allow your knees to roll inward. Place your hands on the front of your hips to feel the TFL and front of the gluteus medius contract with this action.

Step 2)

Follow the instruction from step 1, maintain the cue of pushing away from the midline with your feet and then dial in contraction of the gluteus maximus to lift the pelvis. You will be pushing down and away from the midline to engage your internal rotators and then engaging your glute max to extend the hips. Go up on the exhalation and down on inhalation. Try this about 10 times (2-3 sets). I recommend working with this set of cues for a few days before integrating them into a full back bend. Once you get it, then try the block thing (if you want). You’ll find it works better this way.

(NB: if you experience knee pain in this pose, try pressing down with the heels more--this often helps.)

Figure 4: This illustrates the sheath of muscle surrounding the pelvis and lifting it into the bridge.


I hope you enjoy this post. Use muscle engagement as a barometer to help identify imbalances between the two sides of the body. Then carefully work to balance things. This is one of the benefits of practicing Hatha Yoga using knowledge of anatomy and biomechanics.

Good to see you all again. Check back for Part II in the sequence when I will go over the role of the deep external rotators and discuss synergistic dominance of the hamstrings in more detail.

All the Best,

Ray Long, MD

References:

1) Selkowitz, D. M., Beneck, G. J., & Powers, C. M. (2016). Comparison of Electromyographic Activity of the Superior and Inferior Portions of the Gluteus Maximus Muscle During Common Therapeutic Exercises. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 46(9), 794-799. doi:10.2519/jospt.2016.6493


16 comments:

  1. Thank you, this is extremely informative. I'm a 26 year practitioner/teacher who studied Iyengar exclusively for the first 15 years. I have since learned to study with other experienced therapeutic teachers in different styles, but there has always been enormous confusion about the various gluteal approach to backbends, this exact issue; in fact, I would say that there is no other issue that is quite as consternating. Your explanation is illuminating and, backed by the excellent illustrations and sequence cues, provides a good scientific basis for the approach you suggest. Namaste.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Love the bit especially about "find the motion *first* ... It's difficult to engage once you are up in the pose ..." So true, I think, for many āsana. Thank you for this; very informative!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Ray,
    Your feedback would be appreciated: Lately I've been placing a looped strap around my thighs and pressing outward into the strap for Bridge and Wheel poses. It does wonders to relieve lumbar compression and seems to allow for a smoother action of the pelvis rotating over the femur heads. Is this providing a similar action to what you are describing (pressing outward with the feet)?
    Thank you, AJ

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello, sorry for asking, but what is TFL?

    ReplyDelete
  5. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tensor_fasciae_latae_muscle

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have just been trying this out and it works brilliantly. Thank you for this illuminating post!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Brilliant! Just brilliant! Thank you for finally clearly a cue that has baffled me for years.

    ReplyDelete
  8. you are awesome

    ReplyDelete
  9. I appreciate the sequencing of the cues as well as the reference. How do you cue to avoid having erector spinae initiate and dominate?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Its fantastic. Very easy to make people practice.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great article! I'm going to try this today

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi! I bought all your books and this "extras" you share with us all, are very helpful.
    Thanks for the spirit of shearing and helping.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Your article is great and informative! I am so glad the yoga world continues to evolve and grow - how could it not!!! Iyengar was a master, but not a God, he made mistakes like we all do. Don't stoop yourself by speaking in a degrading way of past mistakes....

    ReplyDelete
  14. Grateful as always, this is fascinating stuff!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hi Ray,
    Thank you for your blog. Its very interesting and very informative. I've bought your books and they are awesome.
    I've got one question: is it possible that adductor muscles prevent me from doing paschimottanasana? I am asking because in janu sirsasana i go deeper than in paschimottanasana and from time to time after paschimottanasana i feel tightening in my groin.

    Thanks in advance!

    ReplyDelete